BBC Sport Scotland reporter Kheredine Idessane has been answering a few of your questions on Celtic.
James requested: Is Brendan Rodgers guilty for an detached begin to the season? On paper the group ought to have progressed into the Champions League. Are the board proper to withhold funds because of numerous monies spent on fairly common gamers? What occurs subsequent?
Commercial
Peter requested: Rodgers appear to have issues with the board releasing funds. Do you suppose he’ll depart?
Kheredine answered: I will take your questions collectively, James and Peter. Rodgers does not get a free cross in all of this, for my part, no.
The present squad, even minus the departed Kyogo Furuhashi and Nicolas Kuhn – and the injured Jota – ought to have had sufficient about them to get previous the champions of Kazakhstan. By no means thoughts failing to attain towards them in 210 minutes. This can be a failure of soccer, of ways, of motivation and doubtlessly of want.
The gamers and supervisor need to take a protracted, onerous have a look at themselves for blowing the membership’s finest likelihood in years to beat their long-standing Champions League qualifying hoodoo.
Commercial
Clearly, earlier and higher recruitment may have helped the membership overcome Kairat Almaty. Rodgers realised this, repeatedly talked about the necessity to strengthen and was successfully ignored by the board. One has to ask why?
This maybe pertains to your level, James, concerning the board being reluctant to spend after they maybe do not feel they acquired worth for cash in Adam Idah, Arne Engels, Auston Trusty or Paulo Bernardo from the 12 months earlier than.
Will Rodgers depart, Peter? On the finish of the season, nearly definitely sure, for my part. Certainly, this complete mess Celtic have gotten themselves into boils right down to supervisor’s future: why would a board sanction a major spend when they do not know who the supervisor goes to be subsequent summer season?
The talks Rodgers had with main shareholder Dermot Desmond over the summer season didn’t result in the provide of a brand new contract. Not sufficient has been fabricated from this, for my part.
Commercial
With a supervisor in place whose deal expires in a couple of months, little marvel we have seen a summer season of hesitation, monetary warning and, by way of the Champions League, soccer failure.
Matt requested: Why do you suppose so many prime gamers appear eager to go away regardless of the success they’ve right here? Greg Taylor, Kuhn, Kyogo, Idah, now rumours of Daizen Maeda eager to go and Yang Yang Hyun-jun being denied, it makes you marvel.
Kheredine answered: There is a shelf-life to a keep in Scotland – definitely for some overseas gamers and home-grown stars with aspiration.
Nobody can blame Taylor for eager to problem himself in a distinct atmosphere. Particularly when there was each likelihood Kieran Tierney could be seen as first-choice left-back.
Commercial
I do not suppose Idah was determined to go away, however there was rising frustration from the stands on the method his Celtic profession was going, and perhaps a bit of frustration within the participant too that he was hardly being offered with a raft of nice possibilities each sport.
A transfer away for an honest return on the £9m Celtic paid for him was good enterprise for everybody.
As for the Japanese lads and Kuhn, the German winger falls exactly into Celtic’s mannequin. Purchase low-cost, promote costly. When the correct provide seems, the membership need to money in, even when it is solely after 18 months.
Kyogo, Maeda and Reo Hatate have all given the membership wonderful service. Kyogo felt he is likely to be suited to a distinct league; Maeda and Hatate are nonetheless there however could really feel they’ve achieved their time, on condition that each arrived in January 2022.
Commercial
With the best respect to our fantastic sport, neither most likely seen Scotland as their finish vacation spot.
The important thing to succession planning is timing, and that is the one factor the Celtic board have loosened their grip on. It ought to have been clear the futures of the supervisor and a number of other key gamers wanted to be resolved early in the summertime. They weren’t and that is why the membership has hit an enormous bump within the street.
[BBC]